‘Unofficial’ Minden 18m Nationals Waypoint Database

With less than a week to go before the official start of the 18m Nationals here at Minden, NV, we contestants still don't have a final waypoint database.  What we do have is an email from CD John Godfrey citing John Leibacher's workload as the excuse for not having the updates out by now, and describing what will be in the final database that is to be ready "Real Soon Now".  IMHO this could and should have, been done months ago when John wasn't swamped with other commitments, but hey - what do I know?  John Leibacher is literally a world-wide soaring treasure, as he manages waypoint databases for ALL worldwide soaring sites, not just the ones in the USA.  We should be working around his work schedule, NOT citing it as the reason for not getting the job done in a timely fashion.

Last winter, when I did my initial waypoint review of the waypoint database used for the 2012 Open Class Nationals, I found a number of problems with the airports/airstrips cited there, and passed that information along to what I thought were the Minden pilots who were managing their waypoint database.  Absolutely nothing resulted from that effort - mostly because of a disconnect between ignorant me and the real 'local' pilots.  The pilots I was talking to weren't the right guys, and the right guys don't even use the contest waypoint database.  Most local pilots use a database maintained by Stu Tattersall, and because no one was regularly flying with the contest database, nobody was bothering to correct the many and obvious mistakes.  So, we have the locals flying one database, and the contest officials promoting another one - wonderful!

I know this now because I'm out here at Minden already, getting in some dual familiarization flights with Soaring NV & XC/Contest pilot Tim Gardner. While getting ready to fly yesterday morning, I also ran into Stu, and made arrangements to sit down with him and Tim Gardner over dinner after flying to see what could be done to make the contest database a bit more pilot-friendly.  So, after we got all the flying done and the gliders put away, we all trooped down to the Taildragger Cafe/Bar to hoist a brew or two and work on database issues.  Dave Nadler (YO) accompanied us and made some valuable inputs to the process.

Here are the disjoint pieces of the Minden waypoint database puzzle:

  • The March 15, 2014 18m contest waypoint database, in theory to be amended with the changes noted in John Godfrey's email and accompanying list of 32 airports that will not be eligible for the 25-point airport bonus.  The problem with this list is that there is no way to tell whether an airstrip on the list is just 'OK, but not very nice' or 'totally unlandable - run away!'  If they really are 'totally unlandable', then they should be removed entirely, giving out-of-town pilots a better chance of making good landout decisions early enough to actually matter.  As it is, we are faced with a Hobson's choice; leave them all in and not know which ones are good landout options, or take them all out and not have potentially life-and-glider saving options when it is needed.
  • Stu Tattersall's extensive Minden XC database, containing a wealth of information about airports, airstrips, and other landout options for the entire Minden soaring area, encompassing much more territory than will be covered in the contest.  Stu maintains this database, and solicits inputs from local pilots, so his information is much more accurate and up to date than the current contest database.
  • Inputs from local pilots like Tim Gardner that may or may not have made it into Stu's database.  Tim flies this area a lot, and has seen many of the airstrips up close and personal.  In addition, Tim and other local pilots (and Stu's database) contain a number of good landout options that aren't in the contest database, but should be.

Over dinner Stu Tattersall, Tim Gardner, Dave Nadler and I tried to figure out how to make the most improvement to the current contest database in a manner that would be least disruptive to contest pilots.  We decided that the way to do this was to go through the 'Godfrey' list of airports that were deemed ineligible for the airport bonus and sort them all into two categories - known to be landable, and known to be unlandable. In addition, landable airports/airstrips not in the contest database would be added.  Once this was done, I would create modified .STX  (ClearNav) and .DAT (everything else except SN10) files, and Dave volunteered to create a similarly modified .NDB (SN10) file.  These would be made available to contest pilots on a 'totally unofficial, to be used at your own risk' basis.

Process:

Verify 'round-trip' capability using Excel and the free Excel to KML converter

There is a cool XLS-KML converter at http://www.earthpoint.us/exceltokml.aspx, so I first sucked the nm_mndn4.dat (CSV-formatted) file into Excel and edited its header to remove all the text and add the required column headers, and then ran it through the converter to produce a KML file viewable in Google Earth.  This allows me to verify that any changes I make actually show up in the right places on the map.

Result from the cool EarthPoint Excel to KML converter.  Even catches mistakes!

Result from the cool EarthPoint Excel to KML converter. Even catches mistakes!

Completely remove airstrips known to be unlandable

Of the 32 airports on the 'Godfrey' list, 19 are known to be unlandable. These waypoints (or at least the  L 'landable' coding in the case of control points) were completely removed.  These are

  • 29 Iowa Canyon
  • 33 Manzanar
  • 39 Ravendale
  • 101 Amedee AAF
  • 103 Barker Creek Ranch
  • 105 Bear Valley
  • 109 Darrow Field
  • 115 Fallon Southwest Airpark
  • 117 Gibb Ranch
  • 120 Justover Field
  • 125 Likely
  • 129 O'toole Ranch
  • 130 Paiute Meadows
  • 131 Palomino
  • 133 Reno/Tahoe International
  • 135 Rolling Thunder
  • 139 Swanson Ranch
  • 140 Tonopah Test Range
  • 143 Youngberg Ranch

Note that waypoint numbers 100 and above are NOT contest control points - they are there only as potential landout options, so they were simply removed from the Excel file. The 4 waypoints that are also contest control points were recoded to remove the 'A' attribute.

The two other waypoints (102 Bailey Ranch and 142 Wineglass Ranch) mentioned in the email were also removed.

Add airports/airstrips from local knowledge

To try and avoid adding to the confusion, these were added with waypoint numbers starting with 200.  Note that the 'DL' after some of these names denotes a 'Dry Lake' landing area.  According to the locals, dry lakes can be perfectly suitable landing areas, BUT trailer retrieves can be difficult to impossible.  The good news is that aero retrieves are usually available from dry lakes.

  • 9 Mile Ranch (38:22:54N, 118:56:21W)
  • USMC STOL (38:21.330N,119:31.140W)
  • ChurchlDL (39:18:01N, 119:02:10W)
  • CoaldalDL (38:05:14N, 117:59:16W)
  • GarfieldFlt (38:22:00N, 118:17:00W)
  • RabbitDL (39:24:55N, 119:23:20W)

Correct any incorrect location coordinates

The only waypoint that had a badly offset symbol was Lantana Ranch, where the waypoint symbol was located over 2 miles south of the actual airport.  This was corrected in the XLS file, and checked using Google Earth.

Modify STX and DAT files accordingly

most soaring database files are just formatted text, so it doesn't take a rocket scientist to manually modify them.  There are a couple of gotchas though - the STX file format is TAB delimited, and it is pretty easy to add an extra tab or inadvertently delete one, as many text editors don't actually show the tab characters.  I use a text editor called TextPad, and it provides an option to make them visible.  Also, when I add a waypoint to an STX file, I generally start by copy/pasting an existing line, and then making sure I don't add or delete any tabs.  The DAT file format is comma-delimited, which poses the same problems as the STX files, but at least in DAT files the delimiting characters are visible by default.

Test the final products

So, how to test the result?  For the DAT file, I simply followed my original process and sucked the modified DAT file into Excel, converted that result to KML and then viewed it in Google Earth. Using this procedure, I was able to verify that the deleted waypoints were indeed gone, the relocated Lantana Ranch waypoint was indeed in the right place, and the added waypoints showed up where they were supposed to (actually, the RabbitDL waypoint was off a bit due to a typo, so the check payed off!)

The STX file is a bit more problematic, as I haven't been able to figure out an easy way to import it into Excel.  The tab-delimited format will import OK, but because the latitude and longitude coordinates are broken up into separate degrees, minutes, and seconds columns, it would take some programming to convert them to the lat/lon numbers that EarthPoint wants :-(.  So, my plan for the STX file is to simply stick it into the ClearNav in the front seat of DX tomorrow and pan around to see if things are where they should be, paying particular attention to Lantana and RabbitDL.

So there you have it - the story of the unofficial, unauthorized, and un-whatever else Minden 18 meter nationals waypoint database.  Assuming that Tim, Dave, or Stu don't find any egregious errors in my work, it should be available in DAT, STX, and NDB (thanks to Dave) format for any pilot who wishes to take his/her chances on my clearly shoddy workmanship ;-).  See Dave Nadler, Tim Gardner, Stu Tattersall or myself for the files.  When you do so, please say thanks to Tim and Stu for giving us the benefit of their local knowledge.

Frank (TA)

Frank Paynter

Dr. Frank (TA) Paynter has a PhD in Electrical Engineering. He retired from a successful 25-year civil-service career in 1993 and spent the next 15 years as a antenna researcher at The Ohio State University in Columbus, OH, retiring again in 2008 to become a full-time soaring bum.He is the author of the book “Cross Country Soaring with Condor”, co-authors (along with Scott Manley) the popular Condor Corner column for ‘Soaring’ magazine, and is a regular contributor to the Condor section at SoaringCafe.com.Along with Mark Hawkins, he is part owner of Hawke Tracking, the company that provides SPOT tracking services for contests and clubs. Before soaring came along, Frank was a national champion skydiver and still holds the record for the most number of consecutive dead-centers in skydiving competition. Frank started soaring in the mid-1990’s at Caesar’s Creek Soaring Club near Waynesville, Ohio and instantly fell in love with Cross-Country racing. Now he goes to as many contests as his wife of over 30 years will allow, and spends his winter months racing and instructing in Condor.

Latest posts by Frank Paynter (see all)

  3 comments for “‘Unofficial’ Minden 18m Nationals Waypoint Database

  1. June 10, 2014 at 6:21 am

    Just curious, why is Reno/Tahoe International unlandable?

  2. Dennis Linnekin
    June 13, 2014 at 11:45 pm

    Reno International should not be on the unlandable list. If a pilot needs to land there, he should check the ATIS, call the Reno Tower and let them know what he needs. It has been mentioned, at one of the Minden 18M pilot meetings this week, that Reno Tower is very easy to work with and quite accommodating.

    • Frank Paynter
      June 14, 2014 at 12:33 am

      Agreed – Reno is reportedly very accomodating, and it certainly should be in any non-contest database. For contests, there is the minor matter of the 1000pt penalty for penetrating Class Charlie airspace, plus the 100pt penalty the next day ;-).

      Frank (TA)

Comments are closed.